THE CAREERS AND HIGHER EDUCATION MAGAZINE FROM THE INSPIRING FUTURES FOUNDATION
Is a specialist degree always a good choice?

Choosing a degree course is a complex business. If you regard your degree as an investment, providing a head start in a particular career, you can opt for a specialist vocational course. If so, research the course carefully, and make sure that it teaches the skills that industry requires.

Broadly, degree courses can be classified into three main types:

Directly vocational courses, essential for a particular career, for instance medicine or architecture.

Vocational courses, ranging from general subjects such as business and management through to more specialist courses like building surveying, retailing, or computer games technology. Some vocational courses sound as if they provide a direct route into a particular industry - but beware, this is not always the case.

Non-vocational courses like history or English literature. Don’t write these off: there is an argument for choosing a subject you’re really interested in, getting good results and then applying for vacancies open to graduates in any subject.

This article is mainly concerned with employers’ opinions of degrees in the second category. With more established professions, particularly those with ‘chartered’ status, there are usually strong links between a specific degree and future employment. However, there are other graduate-level occupations where the relationship is less clear-cut.

Where a specialist degree is important

In an established professional field like surveying, starting with a specialist degree is a great advantage.

Karen Dale, Graduate Recruitment and Placement Manager at international construction consultancy Davis Langdon, recruits surveying graduates, with a preference for those who have specialised in building surveying or quantity surveying.

Karen’s advice on choosing a surveying course is: ‘Look at the RICS (Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors) website, find out about different types of surveying, and use the RICS accredited course list as your starting point. Once you’ve identified a course, look at its links with industry - for instance we have a partnership with certain universities, providing support in terms of academic content.’

Choosing a sandwich course, with a year out in industry, conveys clear benefits, Karen Dale believes. ‘Anyone who’s done a year out placement stands out from the crowd. They may have started working towards their professional qualification, and they will have ‘bedded in’ to office life. It is also common for students on year out placements to be offered permanent employment.’

Where a specialist degree may be useful

Over 40 universities and colleges offer degrees in retailing, and there are excellent opportunities with retail companies, not only in store management but also in fields like e-commerce, marketing and logistics.

Waitrose, the food retailer, sponsors the degree in retail management at Loughborough University, providing student placements, guest lectures, assistance with student projects and visits to head office, stores and distribution centres. Graduates of the course have gone on to successful careers with Waitrose.

‘It’s a really good degree,’ says Anglie Johns, Manager of Recruitment Services at Waitrose. However, although retail management graduates form part of Waitrose’s graduate intake, the business also recruits graduates from a wide range of other disciplines, assessing their suitability on the basis of interpersonal and leadership skills.

Anglie Johns, Recruitment Services Waitrose
Anglie Johns, Recruitment Services Waitrose’

‘In retailing, I wouldn’t say that a vocational degree is essential,’ says Anglie Johns. ‘Everyone is different. When choosing a course I believe it’s important to think about what you’re good at and what you enjoy. When students are thinking about degree courses, they don’t necessarily know how their careers will develop.’

So if you are keen on retailing, a specialist degree can be useful, but isn’t a requirement. There is no accrediting body for retail degrees, but Anglie Johns suggests that the website of the Consortium of Retail Universities as a starting point for research.

Where to tread carefully

With a fast-changing new industry, attractive to students, universities can be tempted to set up courses without taking full account of industry requirements. This is what appears to have happened with computer games courses.

There are around 170 ‘games’ courses in the UK, but only four degrees have been accredited by Skillset, the body which supports skills and training for the games industry. The four accredited courses are listed on Skillset’s website, along with information about job roles within the industry. Another source of information is the Game ON! site produced by leading independent games developers, Blitz Games. These websites describe the different job roles in computer games - which have different skill requirements. You need to understand the different roles before considering courses.

Kim Blake, Education Liaison Officer at Blitz Games, emphasises the importance of training that’s relevant to a specific role. ‘There are a number of courses which are not yet Skillset-accredited but are nonetheless producing good quality graduates. Without exception, they teach the specific skills relating to one discipline, whether that’s art, animation or programming.’

‘What I would say, very clearly, is that we would not recommend courses which offer to teach all elements of development. It may seem a good idea to spend three years learning a bit of animation, a bit of programming, some game design and so on, but the sad fact is that courses such as these do not give graduates the skills they need. There are far too many courses with the word ‘games’ in them which teach nothing of any use.’

Postgraduate instead?

In conclusion, if you are unsure about opting for a vocational degree, remember that specialisation can be at postgraduate level. However, if you are intent on an undergraduate vocational course, then make sure its credentials stand up to scrutiny.

Tips

Is your intended course accredited by a professional institute or industry body?

Does the course have industry partners?

How many graduates from the course are working in the industry?

Four-year sandwich courses - with the third year in industry - are well regarded by employers, and often lead to job offers.

Attend course open days. For computer games courses, Blitz Games Open Days are usually held in March.

Websites

Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS): www.rics.org
Consortium of Retail Universities: www.retailuniversities.org
Skillset: www.skillset.org/games/
Game On! www.BlitzGames.com/Gameon